We went back to the beginning for clues and came up with so many more questions.

ABC Family

1. Am I crazy for wanting to rewatch this? Probably.

2. I wonder if Charles will be in this episode???

3. I forgot they opened with THE NIGHT Ali went missing. This is actually quite a scary opening scene.

4. Random Beyonce reference to show they're ~hip~.

5. Alison really is such a bitch.

6. Why are any of them friends with her for real.

7. Spencer is all "Ali's gone" and it's weird knowing now that she was high AF and would have just had that massive fight with Ali.

8. First shot of Aria is her staring in a mirror. WHAT DOES IT MEAN?!

9. The Montgomery family has been away for a year, and Ali has been missing for a year. So Aria's family just left town straight after Alison disappeared? That seems… odd.

10. OMG Mike was such a BABY in this episode.

11. Oh, this was when the Montgomerys were a happy family. "Happy".

12. Why did it take Aria 45 minutes to get to the bar?

13. Like, what was she doing between dropping Mike off and getting to the bar?! This is very suspicious.

14. Or the creators just screwed up the clocks and it actually has no significance.

15. Meanwhile, what kind of bar serves someone who is clearly a teenager?

16. Oooh here comes Ezra. NGL I ship this version of Ezria a lot.

17. PITY HE WAS THERE TO STALK THE FUCK OUTTA HER AND KNOWS SHE'S 16 YEARS OLD.

18. EZRA YOU CREEP.

19. SMH at this whole scene.

20. "I'd like to know more about you", like all about your missing friend Alison.

21. They totally banged, even though they later tried to pretend they didn't; like why would they go to the privacy of the bathroom to just make out?

22. And then why would Ezra freak out SO MUCH?

23. But then he was faking that too. Because he KNEW she was gonna be at that school.

24. Ugh this is so gross when you know the real situation.

25. Wait is Ezra Charles??!?!

ABC Family

View Entire List ›