As only a gay man and a straight man could decide.

Ira Madison III for BuzzFeed / Via Getty Images

James Cagney

Notable Films: The Public Enemy, Angels With Dirty Faces

Javier Moreno: When you called him a Dick Tracy villain, I thought he actually was Flattop. That was such a horrible movie.

Ira Madison III: First of all, Dick Tracy is iconic.

Javi: Maybe Warren Beatty. Madonna was in it, right?

Ira: Madonna was perfect. Also, I retract my Flattop comment. He looks like the Spider-Man villain Hammerhead.

Javi: Hell yeah! He even has the same pinstripe suit.

Getty Images / Hulton Archive

Robert Mitchum

Notable Films: Cape Fear (1962 version), Crossfire

Ira: So, he has an... interesting look.

Javi: I was gonna say that too. He's got that "hey, wanna see something?" look and you know it's not gonna be good.

Ira: Bless the time when male actors were cast purely on their talent.

Getty Images / Pictorial Parade

View Entire List ›